July 16th, 2011 by Oscar Farber

Normally, we wouldn’t want to go up against fashion power-house Blake Lively in a style contest. After all, she’s a winner time and again.

But when it comes to the frilly gray Isabel Marant frock, Blake’s styling skills were seriously lacking. Leo DiCaprio’s latest flame wore the dress first to unveil the star for the 2010 Rockefeller Center Christmas tree in NYC. The blonde added a busy Isabel Marant jacket, maroon tights and brown ankle boots to create an incredibly mismatched look. Each piece is fantastic by itself, but all together it’s a walking disaster!

Leann Rimes must have taken notes, because months later she wore the same dress, but kept it simple adding only drop earrings and some killer gold sandals. While the tabloid regular’s look doesn’t totally blow us away and the dress is a bit ill-fitting around the bust, we have to say she wins this showdown by default!

Or are you more of a fan of Blake’s cold-weather look? You wouldn’t be alone, as Leann’s ex-husband is reportedly obsessed with the Gossip Girl star.

Similar Posts:

• The Holiday Season’s Hottest Dress Trends: Accessorize for Under $10
• Must-have maxi dresses
• Style Showdown: Posh Shows Olivia Palermo How It’s Done!
• Emerging Footwear Trend: Pointed Toe Shoes
• Who Broke the Bank? Katherine Heigl or Maggie Q?